Tesla Model Y Vs. Volkswagen ID.4: Comparison

Have you been comparing the Tesla Model Y vs. Volkswagen ID.4 but still can't make a decision? Don't worry; plenty of buyers who want to go all-electric face this conundrum. Both vehicles seem like great choices on paper, but one has to come out on top.

These SUVs can be similar in their features, design, and performance, but there are also plenty of differences when you take a closer look. Here are the facts you need to know about each one to make an informed decision.

Tesla Model Y vs. Volkswagen ID.4 Features

These two models are jam-packed with features. Both can have a panoramic glass roof, wireless mobile charging for compatible devices, USB charging ports throughout the vehicle, heated seats, and a touch-screen interface. However, with the VW model, there is available massaging functionality for both front seats. This feature is not included with any trim level for the Tesla Model Y.

When comparing the Volkswagen ID.4 vs. Tesla Model Y, you might notice that the Tesla touch screen is bigger by a little over two inches, but this doesn't necessarily mean that it is better. For example, both vehicles allow you to control the temperature of your car. However, many consumers have found the physical buttons in the VW ID.4 to be easier to use than the Tesla Model Y tech-centered interface.

Tesla Model Y vs. Volkswagen ID.4 Interior

The interiors of the Tesla Model Y vs. Volkswagen ID.4 are very different, especially when it comes to the seating fabric. Tesla automakers have custom-engineered specialty vegan seating that is supposedly great at resisting stains and maximizing comfort.

However, this comes down strictly to your personal preference, as some drivers strongly dislike the feel of this fabric. The VW ID.4, on the other hand, provides more traditional options, such as leatherette seating surfaces.

Tesla Model Y vs. Volkswagen ID.4 Dimensions

When you drive a new vehicle, you can instantly feel the difference in size from your daily driver. Some like the idea of being the biggest car on the road, while others prefer more compact rides as they can be easier to handle and park.

As a midsize SUV, the Tesla Model Y is noticeably larger at 187.0 inches long, compared to the compact Volkswagen ID.4, which is 180.5 inches long. Part of this is because you can upgrade to a Tesla Model Y seven-seater, while the Volkswagen ID.4 has five seats as the only available option. However, opting for a three-row Tesla Model Y will severely restrict your cargo space, giving you 17 cubic feet. Even if you fold the third row down, you will only have access to 26.6 cubic feet of storage room. Meanwhile, the Volkswagen ID.4 offers more than 30 cubic feet behind its second row.

Tesla Model Y vs. Volkswagen ID.4 Performance

These models both feature an all-wheel drive and rear-wheel drive option, so our focus will be on their handling and the driver experience.

The Tesla Model Y is known for its quick acceleration, but the stiffer suspension and inconsistent build quality can make it a rougher ride. The Volkswagen ID.4, on the other hand, is gentler and won't throw you back in your seat, but it isn't so slow that it is difficult to reach higher speeds.

You also have various drive modes with the VW ID.4, including Eco, Comfort, Sport, and Custom, that make it adaptable to different driving situations. It allows you to choose between an athletic feel, similar to the Tesla Model Y, or something more laid back for a pleasant drive through the countryside. The Tesla Model Y only offers three drive modes, called acceleration modes. Depending on which configuration you select, they are Chill, Standard, and Sport.

Tesla Model Y vs. Volkswagen ID.4 Warranty Options

Battery capacity and vehicle health are among the most crucial factors to consider when discussing electric vehicles, and these automakers don't take their batteries lightly. Rest easy knowing you'll be covered for several years and thousands of miles with either model.

The Tesla Model Y (Long Range All-Wheel Drive or Performance variants) will come from the manufacturer with a battery warranty covering up to eight years or 120,000 miles, whichever comes first.⁵ Pay careful attention to your date of purchase and the mileage on your vehicle to stay up-to-date on your warranty coverage and eligibility.

There is also another caveat. A Tesla Model Y warranty will only stay active if the battery remains at a minimum of 70% retention of its original capacity during the warranty period. Please note that the rear-wheel drive Model Y only gets warranty coverage for up to eight years or 100,000 miles maximum.⁵

With a Volkswagen ID.4, the battery warranty is good for up to eight years or 100,000 miles (whichever comes first) for your new ID.4.⁵ This is the same as the warranty for the RWD variant of the Tesla Model Y. However, you will get additional benefits that the Tesla model does not to help you avoid potential issues, such as the Carefree Coverage program.

The Carefree Coverage program covers maintenance costs and services to keep your new VW ID.4 in tip-top shape over two years or 20,000 miles — whichever comes first.⁶ Tesla automakers used to offer a complimentary maintenance program but recently suspended it.

Thoughtful warranty coverage and Carefree Coverage can be found for all new Volkswagen cars for sale.

Tesla Model Y vs. Volkswagen ID.4 Range

One of the biggest questions customers often ask is how far these SUVs can take them on a single charge. When looking at the Tesla Model Y vs. Volkswagen ID.4, you will notice that the Tesla model will take you slightly further, but the VW model comes with its own unique advantages.

Here are the potential ranges for your 2024 Tesla Model Y or VW ID.4:

• VW ID.4 Standard / ID.4 S: EPA-estimated 206 miles¹
• VW ID.4 Pro / ID.4 Pro S: EPA-estimated 291 miles²
• VW ID.4 AWD Pro / ID.4 AWD Pro S: EPA-estimated 263 miles³
• Tesla Model Y Rear-Wheel Drive: EPA-estimated 260 miles⁴
• Tesla Model Y Performance: EPA-estimated 285 miles⁴
• Tesla Model Y Long Range All-Wheel Drive: EPA-estimated 310 miles⁴

Any of these models has the ability to take you a great distance. Consider that most Americans drive 37 miles per day.⁷ However, if you are planning a cross-country road trip, recharging is likely inevitable regardless of whether you pick the Tesla or Volkswagen model. The Volkswagen SUV can charge from 10% to 80% in 29 minutes, utilizing a DC Fast charger.⁸ As an added benefit, Volkswagen drivers receive complimentary Charging at Electrify America stations (30-minute charges for up to three years).⁹

Makers of the Tesla Model Y only advertise that you can add 160 miles of charge in 15 minutes.⁸ However, you will find many caveats to this number. Charging isn't a consistent process. EVs are often built to throttle charging at certain points to help extend the life span of the battery, so you can't assume the Tesla model could be fully charged up in 30 minutes based on their given data. In addition, they are counting on you using a Tesla Supercharging location rather than the more traditional DC Fast-Charging stations spread throughout the country. A Tesla model would not charge as fast using this system.

Tesla Model Y vs. Volkswagen ID.4 Price

While looking over some of the specs for the Volkswagen ID.4 vs. Tesla Model Y, it becomes clear that these two are neck and neck across many categories. However, the VW offering gives the Tesla model a run for its money with its lower starting price. The Tesla option tries to advertise itself as having a lower MSRP. However, that price subtracts the Federal Tax Credit given to select all-electric vehicles. As of this writing, the new VW ID.4 for sale also qualifies for this same incentive.¹⁰

You should also keep in mind that while the Tesla Model Y might have a higher range, many of its features are add-ons that you will have to pay extra for in your final price. On the other hand, the Volkswagen ID.4 has always offered exceptional value when you consider its appealing MSRP.

Secure Your Volkswagen ID.4 Today

Have you decided that the Volkswagen ID.4 is the SUV for you? If so, stop by O'Steen Volkswagen, our Volkswagen dealer in Jacksonville. We can help you acquire your new VW ID.4 or explore other options within this family of vehicles. Our associates here at our dealership are ready to walk you through the process when you decide it's time to claim your next Volkswagen vehicle.

Have more questions regarding the Tesla Model Y vs. Volkswagen ID.4 comparison? Feel free to reach out to our sales team at O'Steen Volkswagen of Jacksonville, or keep reading to learn the answers to your most pressing inquiries.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the Volkswagen ID.4 a good car?

The Volkswagen ID.4 is a good car for those looking for a comfortable all-electric SUV. Advantages include a roomy cabin where you can comfortably stretch your legs, a smooth ride that every driver will enjoy, and an impressive range of up to 291 miles.² You can enjoy luxurious amenities like heated first- and second-row seats and front seats with massage functionality.

Is the ID.4 an SUV?

The Volkswagen ID.4 is not only an SUV, but it is also breaking ground as an affordable, all-electric alternative to similar gas-powered vehicles. It has available all-wheel drive and impresses drivers with its incredible traction on various terrains. If you're looking for a practical family driver but also want to keep your carbon footprint in check, the ID.4 may be right for you.

How much does the Tesla Model Y cost?

Tesla Model Y pricing depends on what powertrain model you choose. The MSRP that Tesla automakers advertise is also a bit misleading since it includes the adjusted cost after taking a $7,500 federal tax credit.¹⁰ Many other automakers state their starting price as what it is before incentives are applied. However, for a current quote, you should speak directly to a dealership.

How long is the wait for the Tesla Model Y?

The wait for a Tesla Model Y order is not always consistent and could depend on availability, location, and the specific model that you choose. The overall quality of the Tesla model is also a moving target, as this all-electric automaker is constantly making updates throughout the year. On the other hand, no matter when you order a Volkswagen ID.4, you know exactly what you're getting.

Volkswagen Model Research In Jacksonville, FL

---

¹2024 Volkswagen ID.4 Standard / ID.4 S EPA-estimated total range is 206 miles. Actual mileage and range will vary and depend on several factors including driving and charging habits, accessory use, temperature and topography, battery age, load, and vehicle condition. Battery capacity decreases with time and use. See owner's manual for details.

²2024 Volkswagen ID.4 Pro / ID.4 Pro S EPA-estimated total range is 291 miles. Actual mileage and range will vary and depend on several factors including driving and charging habits, accessory use, temperature and topography, battery age, load, and vehicle condition. Battery capacity decreases with time and use. See owner's manual for details.

³2024 Volkswagen ID.4 AWD Pro / ID.4 AWD Pro S EPA-estimated total range is 263 miles. Actual mileage and range will vary and depend on several factors including driving and charging habits, accessory use, temperature and topography, battery age, load, and vehicle condition. Battery capacity decreases with time and use. See owner's manual for details.

⁴Estimates only. For more information, please visit the official U.S. government source for all fuel economy at www.fueleconomy.gov

⁵Warranties listed on this web page shall not be solely relied upon. Warranties may be subject to specific terms, restrictions, exclusions, and fees. Additional warranty information may be obtained by visiting the official website of the warranty provider. Contact our dealership for complete details.

⁶VW’s Carefree Maintenance program provides the 10,000- and 20,000-mile scheduled maintenance services or scheduled maintenance services for two years (whichever occurs first) as stated in the vehicle’s maintenance booklet on all new MY24 vehicles. See dealer or owner’s literature for provided services, exclusions, and time and other limitations. The Carefree Maintenance program does not provide tire rotations, or other services or parts not specified in the owner’s literature.

⁷This information is not verified by the official manufacturer and shall serve solely as unofficial general information. For details, visit: https://www.kbb.com/car-advice/average-miles-driven-per-year/

⁸Charging times may vary and are influenced by several factors, including but not limited to outdoor temperature, battery temperature, charging equipment, battery condition, and the overall condition of the vehicle. For precise information on charging times for a specific vehicle model, please contact our dealership.

⁹Available on new model year 2024 Volkswagen ID.4 vehicles purchased from an authorized U.S.-based Volkswagen dealer. Thirty-six (36) months of Pass+ pricing and 500 kWh of complimentary DC Fast or L2 charging begins upon vehicle purchase. Complimentary charging does not include any idle fees and their associated or applicable taxes assessed at the charging station. You will be responsible for paying such fees through your account if you incur them during a charging session. Non-transferable. Not available for commercial use, such as ride-hailing and ridesharing. Requires Electrify America account, app, acceptance of Terms of Use, Privacy Policy, Promotion Terms and Conditions, enrollment in VW ID.4 Charging Plan, and $10 deposit to pre-fund idle fees, which may be automatically reloaded. See Terms of Use for details. Unused idle fee deposit will be refunded when account is closed. After benefits terminate or expire, your account will convert to a basic Electrify America "Pass" account. Your actual charging speed may vary.

¹⁰At the time of writing. Incentives are subject to change without notice and are intended for informational purposes only. Please note that this is not tax advice. Consult with your tax adviser for further details and to determine eligibility.